What If I Don't Have Enough Equity to Pay the Tax Liens When I Sell?

First, We Need the Real Numbers

This isn't the time for estimates such as:

“I think I owe the IRS around $40,000.”

Or:

“My mortgage is probably about $500,000.”

We need better information.

That may include:

• Expected market value of the property
• Current mortgage payoff
• Home equity or second mortgage balances
• Federal tax liens
• California state tax liens
• Delinquent property taxes
• Judgments or other recorded liens
• HOA obligations
• Estimated selling and closing expenses

Once escrow and title are involved, appropriate payoff or demand information can be requested.

For California FTB liens, the state specifically instructs escrow, title or mortgage companies to help resolve liens during escrow and use its eDemand process to request payoff information.

Then we can stop guessing.

Not Enough Equity for WHAT?

This is one of the most important questions.

Imagine a property that might sell for $500,000.

There could be:

$420,000 first mortgage

$50,000 IRS lien

$25,000 California tax lien

plus selling expenses.

Clearly, $500,000 isn't enough to simply pay every number in full.

But that doesn't tell us what the solution is.

We need to determine:

Which liens affect the property?

When were they recorded?

What is their priority?

What proceeds are actually available?

What must happen for clear title to transfer?

Does any creditor have a process that could permit the sale despite receiving less than the full debt?

This is why I don't want homeowners attempting to solve the transaction with a calculator and an internet search.

The numbers are only the beginning.

A Tax Lien Doesn't Necessarily Have to Disappear From Your Entire Life

Here's an important concept.

There can be a difference between:

eliminating the taxpayer's entire tax debt

and

allowing a particular property to be sold free of the lien.

For federal tax liens, the IRS has a process called a discharge of property.

A discharge removes the federal tax lien from a specific property under qualifying circumstances. It does not necessarily eliminate the taxpayer's underlying tax liability.

That's an important distinction.

The question may not always be:

“Can I pay my entire IRS debt?”

It may be:

“What does the IRS require in order for this particular property to be transferred?”

That's something the appropriate professionals and taxing authority need to determine based upon the actual transaction.

What If the IRS Tax Lien Can't Be Paid in Full?

This is where federal tax lien discharge procedures can potentially become relevant.

The IRS recognizes several circumstances under which specific property may qualify for discharge from a federal tax lien.

For example, one provision addresses situations where debts senior to the federal tax lien exceed the property's fair market or sale value—meaning the government's interest in that particular property may have no value. Another can involve partial satisfaction based upon the value of the government's interest in the property.

That's very different from saying:

“The IRS will forgive whatever doesn't get paid.”

I would never promise that.

Instead:

We determine what the IRS's secured interest in this particular property is and what process may be available to allow the sale to close.

The taxpayer may still owe unpaid tax debt after the property is sold.

That's a tax matter—not something I would attempt to resolve as the real estate broker.

What About a California State Tax Lien?

California also specifically anticipates situations where escrow doesn't contain enough money to pay all liens.

The Franchise Tax Board tells sellers in real estate transactions that escrow/title should obtain the appropriate payoff information. Its lien guidance separately directs transactions with insufficient proceeds to its “Insufficient funds in escrow/short sale” process.

Again, that doesn't mean:

“FTB automatically takes whatever is left and releases everything.”

It means there is an established process for addressing situations where the transaction doesn't have enough proceeds to simply pay the lien in full.

That's why we identify the problem early.

Is This a Short Sale?

Maybe. Maybe not.

This is where terminology can become confusing.

If the property doesn't have enough value to satisfy the mortgage and the mortgage lender is being asked to accept less than the amount required to release its lien, then we may be dealing with a traditional mortgage short sale.

But suppose the mortgage can be paid in full and the shortage exists because of a junior tax lien.

That's a different situation.

Or perhaps there are several liens with different priorities.

Different lienholders may need to be addressed differently.

So I wouldn't hear:

“There isn't enough equity.”

and immediately conclude:

“We need a short sale.”

I'd say:

“Let's see where the shortage actually is.”

Lien Priority Matters

This is another reason these transactions need to be evaluated individually.

Simply looking at the dollar amount of each lien doesn't tell us how sale proceeds must be handled.

Different liens can have different priorities, and federal/state tax liens can interact with mortgages, property taxes and other claims in complicated ways.

California FTB even maintains separate guidance for transactions involving competing state and federal tax liens.

This is where my job isn't to practice tax law.

My job is to recognize:

We have a title problem that needs to be resolved before we can close.

Then we get escrow, title and, when appropriate, tax or legal professionals involved.

What If the Mortgage Is Also Underwater?

Now we're potentially dealing with two layers of shortage.

Suppose:

The house is worth less than the mortgage balance.

And there is also a tax lien.

Now the mortgage lender may need to approve a short sale and the tax lien may need to be appropriately addressed.

That makes the transaction more complicated, but complicated isn't the same as impossible.

This is exactly why I want to know about every lien at the beginning.

We don't want to spend months obtaining lender approval and then discover immediately before closing that another lien prevents title from transferring.

What If There Is a Partial Claim Too?

Here's another surprise homeowners sometimes encounter.

Someone may have previously completed a loan modification and later discover there is a partial claim or subordinate deed of trust associated with that modification.

Now the financial picture could include:

First mortgage.

Partial claim.

Tax lien.

Selling expenses.

Possibly other liens.

A homeowner who thought there was equity can suddenly discover there isn't nearly as much as expected.

Again:

Don't assume. Get the numbers.

What If I Have Several Different Tax Liens?

Then we need to identify each one individually.

For example, you could potentially have both:

Federal IRS lien

and

California FTB lien.

Those aren't simply combined into one generic bucket called “tax liens.”

Each taxing authority has its own claim and procedures.

And when state and federal liens compete for limited proceeds, priority becomes especially important. California specifically directs those situations to its competing-liens process.

That's why the correct strategy isn't:

“Let's divide whatever money is left between everybody.”

The transaction needs to be handled according to the applicable lien rights, approvals and requirements.

Don't Automatically Bring Money to Closing

This is another assumption I wouldn't make.

A homeowner sees a projected shortage of $40,000 and thinks:

“I guess I need $40,000 to sell.”

Maybe.

But don't write the check yet.

First determine:

What liens actually need to be paid.

What their current payoff amounts are.

What their priority is.

Whether any applicable discharge, release, short-sale or other process may be available.

Whether the mortgage lender needs to participate.

And what amount would actually be required from the seller, if anything.

Find the problem before funding the problem.

Don't Automatically Walk Away From the Sale Either

The opposite reaction can also be premature.

Someone discovers:

House value: $500,000

Total debts and expenses: $550,000

and decides:

“Well, I can't sell.”

Not so fast.

The face amount of all debts isn't necessarily the same thing as the amount that must come from this particular transaction for the property to be transferred.

That is especially important with federal tax liens because the IRS expressly provides procedures for discharging specific property from a lien under qualifying circumstances.

We need to investigate before concluding the sale can't happen.

What Happens to Tax Debt That Isn't Paid Through the Sale?

This is where the real-estate conversation ends and the tax conversation begins.

Selling the property does not necessarily erase unpaid tax debt.

A taxing authority agreeing to release or discharge its lien from a particular property is not necessarily the same as forgiving the taxpayer's remaining liability.

That's something the homeowner needs to discuss with the taxing authority and/or a qualified tax professional or attorney.

I don't want someone reading this page and thinking:

“Great! Dawn can make my tax debt disappear.”

Nope. 😂

I sell real estate.

What I can do is help determine whether there may be a path to selling the property despite the tax lien.

Those are two different problems.

Why Starting Early Matters

This isn't the kind of title problem I'd want to discover three days before closing.

For example, federal lien discharge requests can require documentation about the transaction, liens, valuation and proposed escrow. IRS Publication 783 explains the application process and supporting documentation involved.

California's FTB similarly requires transaction and lien information for payoff requests.

That means time is our friend.

If you already know there are significant tax liens and little equity, tell me at the beginning.

That gives us time to identify what we're dealing with and determine who needs to become involved.

What If I Don't Know Whether I Have Enough Equity?

That's completely fine.

You don't need to calculate this yourself.

Start with:

What might the house realistically sell for?

Then we begin identifying:

Mortgage balances.

Known tax liens.

Other liens.

Estimated transaction expenses.

From there, title and escrow information can help us develop a much clearer picture.

Sometimes the homeowner who thought there was no equity discovers the transaction works.

Sometimes the homeowner who thought there was plenty of equity discovers another lien they didn't know existed.

Either way:

I'd rather know.

So What If There Isn't Enough Equity to Pay the Tax Liens?

We don't panic.

And we don't promise.

We investigate.

We determine:

1. What the property is realistically worth.

2. What liens actually affect the property.

3. The current payoff amounts.

4. The priority of the liens.

5. How much money the transaction is expected to produce.

6. Which lienholder or taxing authority isn't going to be paid in full.

7. What process, if any, may allow that particular lien to be addressed so the property can transfer.

And if specialized tax or legal advice is required, we involve the appropriate professional.

That's how you turn:

“I can't sell because I don't have enough equity.”

into:

“Let's find out whether that's actually true.”

Not Enough Equity to Pay Your Tax Liens? Let's Look at the Whole Picture.

If you want to sell a California property but the mortgage, tax liens and other obligations appear to exceed the available proceeds, don't automatically assume you're stuck.

And don't assume every creditor will simply accept less either.

These transactions have to be evaluated individually.

I've been a California real estate broker for more than 26 years and have extensive experience with short sales and complicated property transactions throughout Southern California.

You don't need to know which lien has priority.

You don't need to know whether you need a short sale.

And you don't need to figure out IRS or FTB procedures before calling me.

Tell me what you know. We'll start with the property and the numbers and determine what needs to be investigated next.

Call Dawn Anderson, Broker — Midas Realty Group

Tax-lien priority, lien discharge, lien release, short-sale requirements and treatment of unpaid tax liabilities depend upon the taxing authority, lien, ownership, other encumbrances and individual circumstances. Approval of a property sale for less than all outstanding obligations is not guaranteed. Tax and legal questions should be addressed with the applicable taxing authority and appropriately qualified tax or legal professionals. This post provides general real estate information and is not legal, tax or financial advice.

AREAS WE SERVE

California Probate Real Estate

Los Angeles Probate Realtor

Orange County Probate Realtor

Riverside Probate Realtor

San Bernardino Probate Realtor

San Diego probate Realtor